My Favourite Fantasy Standalone Novels
On December 13, when I began my two-part post on my Favourite Epic Fantasy series, I promised that I would post on standalone novels “laterz.”
As part of the background to that post, I also explained that the drive to pen lists was partly because I’d received a few communications along the lines of:
“I don’t normally read fantasy but I enjoyed your books (HL: thank you!) and would like to read more, so what would you recommend?”
The best way to recommend seemed to be sharing what I have liked over the years. With this list though, it’s just “Fantasy” because I honestly couldn’t think of 10 standalone epic fantasy novels—epic really does seem to run to series! I should also note that I tried to stick to one book per author, otherwise around four on my list would be by Guy Gavriel Kay. And yes, I know my reading “slip” is now showing, but hey—just sayin’ 😉
I am very open though to hearing your suggestions for further, specifically epic—but in fact any!—standalone fantasy reading: comment at will!
I also note that:
- The list is in alphabetical order by author, so there is no preference implied by the order in which the books appear
- I am not including children’s fiction—these are all Adult or at least YA/Crossover reads. I will post on Children’s/YA books as a separate topic(s).
—
Marion Zimmer Bradley: The Mists of Avalon
Although I was subsequently to read a huge number of retellings of the Arthurian legends (possibly too many in fact!) The Mists of Avalon was the very first such retelling I encountered—and I loved it! I was enthralled by its interweaving of Celtic myth and real history, and the combination of politics and battles and magic, romantic and sexual relationships—but most of all that the entire story was told from the perspective of the women in the Arthurian cycle. That was definitely a first for me in my Fantasy reading and one I liked, opening up the notion that women’s history and women’s voices in and through storytelling had something to say: something that mattered.
CJ Cherryh: The Paladin
I suspect The Paladin is one of CJ Cherryh’s less-known works, but I’ve loved it since first re-reading. Set in a medieval Sino-Japanese conceived world, it tells the story of Taizu, a young woman with a vengeance mission, and Shoka, the former general and warlord living in exile on the edge of the realm. The heart of the book is not the epic quest, but the relationship between Taizu and Shoka—and in particular, for me, the character of Shoka, who is a patchwork of expereince and disillusion, self interest, guile, and reluctant integrity, that is perhaps best ‘caught’ by a companion’s summation toward the end of the book: “It was him, in all that glitter. Same eyes, same mouth. Same conniving scoundrel.”
Ru Emerson: The Princess of Flames
This is another book—and writer, sadly—that you don’t hear a lot about now, but The Princess of Flames is such a great story, with a skilfully drawn medieval world, and an interesting but not overly elaborate magic system that draws on a version of the tarot deck. The characters are fascinating and well-drawn, with the story picking up both the tensions and power-plays within a family, with similar forces playing out on a different scale within and between realms. Elfrid, the central protagonist, is a wonderful heroine: a woman forced by situation to become a soldier of fortune, who feels very ‘real’ both emotionally and in that role.
Raymond E Feist: Faerie Tale
This is the first Fantasy novel I can recall reading which brought faerie and magic so strongly into the contemporary everyday world, but also did so in a way that had overtones of Horror. In that sense it made quite an impression and I particularly liked the way traditional figures such as Oberon, Titania and Puck were re-imagined in an American setting and with a new twist added to the old stories.
Neil Gaiman: Neverwhere
Confession—I first read Neverwhere very recently, but I still feel it may be quite my favourite Neil Gaiman book (with the ‘possible’ exception of The Graveyard Book.). I just love the whole idea of an alternate realm below London (“London Below”—and yes, it does predate Mieville’s Un Lun Dun, just in case you’re wondering) and the sheer imagination of the story, the world—with elements such as the Floating Market, the Earl’s Court and the Angelus—and an array of wonderful characters. I love the central characters of Door, the Marquis, and Richard Mayhew—of course—but I think its a toss up between the ‘Russian Doll’ nature of Islington, and the villains Croup and Vandemar, for the characters I can’t help enjoying the most. This is a fun, but most of all a really imaginative read. Did I say I love it already? Well, I definitely do!
Barbara Hambly: Dragonsbane
I know, I know, you’re going to say there are sequels to Dragonsbane, but to me it’s like the movie Matrix–there’s really only one movie and the sequels don’t really exist! The thing I love about Dragonsbane is that it is perfect, whole and complete just as it is—and I love the story, which at one level is about the nature of power, and duty, and the choices we make about those things as societies and individuals; at another about a reluctant dragon slayer, who is unheroic in his approach to the task but heroic in being prepared to take it on; and about a woman stepping fully into her power—and all the authentic Hambly interplay between these elements. Plus featuring one of my all-time favourite dragons: Morkeleb the Black.
Mark Helprin: Winter’s Tale
I think this story is technically “magic realism” although to me it is more a kind of historical urban fantasy—beginning in a 19th century New York that is to all intents and purposes real—except for the magic: a white horse that rediscovers flight, a pursuit that traverses a century, a bridge of light to infinity… But really the heart of the book is the world, and the world is New York—Manhattan and Brooklyn and Up State—in a variant of ‘Gangs of New York’ meets ‘Westside Story.’ It’s a rich, mythic, and utterly fabulous world, more than well worth a read.
Guy Gavriel Kay: Tigana
Guy Gavriel Kay is one of the few fantasy novelists I can think of who has written more standalone novels than series—and Tigana is one of my favourites. Like many of Kay’s novels it is based on real history (in this case that of renaissance Italy) but transforms it into a distinctive story. Like most of Kay’s standalones it is also “magic-light” although there is always a thread of magic in the story—but the element that makes the story wonderful is the emotional realism and depth of the characters. Dianora, in particular, is probably one of my favourite fantasy heroines.
Patricia McKillip: The Forgotten Beasts of Eld
Patricia McKillip is one of my most-loved authors, and her Riddlemaster of Hed trilogy featured as one of my favourite Epic Fantasy series. I have also enjoyed many of her standalones, but The Forgotten Beasts of Eld was the first one I read and has been an enduring favourite. Like many of McKillip’s novels it is written in a very poetic (but not inaccessible) style that suits the High Fantasy-Romantic tale involving mythic beasts, high magic, warring kingdoms, doomed love, the price of power and of vengeance, and the heroine’s journey toward understanding of both herself and others. A classic Fantasy novel, in my opinion, which fittingly won the World Fantasy Award in 1975 and was reprinted by Gollancz as one of its Fantasy Masterworks series.
Tim Powers: The Drawing of the Dark
Although not a retelling like The Mists of Avalon, this story also owes a debt to the Arthurian cycle. As the story unfolds we learn that the main character, a freebooting, Renaissance-era sword-for-hire, is actually infused by the spirit of Arthur, and through Arthur, the older hero archetype of Sigurd/Sigismund (may I say, really loved that aspect to the story.) He also gets caught up in the Ottoman seige of Vienna, which was indeed an epic battle of its day, although I tend to think of this story as a nice mix of myth and history, rather than epic fantasy per se. But it’s a longstanding favourite and one which also plays to my love of swashbuckling and adventurous storytelling. As for the Dark—it’s definitely not your bog-standard epic “dark”, but you’ll have to read the book yourself to find out what I mean. 😉
—
So there you have it—ten of my favourite standalone, (largely Adult) Fantasy reads—but tell me, what would you add to the list?
Especially these days, standalone fantasy novels are an uncommon breed. I do like some of your choices here. I am amused by your Hambly comment, because when I saw the cover, I said “Wait…” in my mind.
To your list, I will add three:
Silverlock, John Myers Myers. One of my desert island books, even if it is frightfully dated. Shandon Silverlock, with a BA in Business Admin and no heart for culture, winds up in land of story and myth, and learns better. He meets Circe, hangs out with Robin Hood, visits Heorot Hall, and he’s just getting started….
The Compleat Traveller in Black, John Brunner. Really a story cycle rather than a novel, its the story of an agent of Order whose mission is to reduce the Chaos in the world, and turn the world to a more regular place. (and yes, a place where he himself would not fit…)
War for the Oaks, Emma Bull. Long before I moved to Minneapolis, I read this wonderous book about Faeries clashing, secretly in a city far to the west of me. Strong female protagonist, great feel for the City of Lakes.
He-he re ‘Dragonsbane’–‘Dune’ is another book that remains a standalone ‘in my mind’, but SF so not for this list!
I have heard of War for the Oaks but not the other two, so will definitely have to give them a try. There is a good specialist store here that I will try first.
Ooh, thanks for this list! Always trying to find more fantasy stand alones, but it can be hard. I hadn’t heard of some of these, so will give them a try. 🙂
There’s also K.J. Parker’s stand alone novels. And Diana Wynne Jones has some great ones too, though not epic fantasy. Zoo City is a great urban fantasy, and Railsea is a wonderful book. Those might end up with sequels I suppose, but for now they both work well on their own. Er… and now I’m at a loss, unless I just list more Guy Gavriel Kay books!
Hi Victoria, I haven’t got to KJ Parker yet though have heard good things so ‘will definitely do’ in the future.:) I love Diana Wynne Jones but have her down for the Children’s/YA list for now (although which book to choose—so many great reads in her oeuvre!) And although Zoo City was touted as SciFi I totally agree with you that it’s Fantasy; but you are right to suspect that it is a series, I just don’t think the second book is out as yet.
Railsea, like KJ Parker, is still on the TBR list, but thinking about it, a book like Perdido Street Station might count as a form of epic fantasy. Hmmm…
I’m already tempted to cheat as I would recommend Gene Wolfe’s two book series The Wizard Knight, especially as it is really just one long book (like Connie Willis’ Blackout/All Clear).
Stardust in addition to your Neverwhere recommendation by Neil Gaiman.
Pretty much any Patricia A. McKillip novel. I think my favorite is Ombria in Shadow.
I’m having a real hard time thinking of anything besides those which would be anything close to “epic”.
I can think of stand-alone urban fantasy and/or mythology/folklore novels like Terri Windling’s excellent The Wood Wife but not a lot of epic fantasy.
Carl, I feel a duology *would* be cheating (otherwise I could have included David Gemmell’s Lion of Macedon/Dark Prince.) 😉
I haven’t read Stardust yet (though have seen the film, but understand they’re reasonably different) and The Wood Wife is also on the TBR list. (It is a longlist though, alas!)
Ombria In Shadow is another of my McKillip “Top Reads.” In fact am thinking I must get my ‘very own copy.’ I also adore the Kinuko Craft covers for McKillip’s books and feel her artistic style goes with the stories extraordinarily well.
“Just thinking” though in relation to epic fantasy standalones, what about David Gemmell’s The Knights of Dark Renown—I think that might just fit the bill.
Hurrah for “Dragonsbane” – the sequels are rubbish but it is a wonderful book, she is very under rated as a fantasy writer and has some great series.
I am also please to see “Tigana” which is probably my favourite fantasy novel in the entire world – it STILL makes me cry at the end despite umpteen readings. He has also written, as standalones the excellent “Under Heaven”, “A Song for Arbonne” and “The Lions of Al-Rassan” – if you like your fantasy heroic and with a dash of self-sacrifice you can’t do better.
Anne, I am a “huge” Barbara Hambly fan and wish she was still writing Fantasy. And snap to Tigana being wonderful although I also rate A Song for Arbonne very highly and the other two you mention would also be my GGK 3 and 4. And I do very much like my Fantasy heroic and with a dash of sacrifice, not to mention Kay also doing High Fantasy-Romantic extraordinarily well.
“Tigana” scores by having one of the most frustrating endings of any book ever !!
Anne, I know what you mean, but I still love the ending–for me it’s ‘perfect’ for the book. I love the way that as one story closes, another opens–but we are not on that particular train…
I’m organising my Kindle ‘to buy’ list as we speak!!! 🙂
Thanks Helen
R
Well, I remembered you were looking for new Fantasy reads, so thought I’d give a shout-out re this list.:)
Great list – glad to see Tigana there – first one that I thought of when I saw the heading on you twitter feed.
Another ten for you to consider, some from authors mainly known for their epic series, and some from authors who tend to write stand alone novels.
All worth checking out if you have the inclination.
Freda Warrington – Rainbow Gate
Tad Williams -The War of the Flowers
Elizabeth Hand – Waking the Moon
Robin McKinley – Deerskin
Alan Dean Foster – Into the out of
Terry Pratchett – Nation
Sheri S Tepper – Beauty
David & Leigh Eddings – The Redemption of Althus
Sarah Ash – Songspinners
Susanne Clarke – Jonathan Strange & Mr Norell
Some great books on that list, Giles–I had completely forgotten Freda Warrington! But I must confess that I am, alas, not a fan of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell — my bad, I suspect, since so many do love it.
But Tigana, yes: it’s definitely a ‘classic’ in my book! 😉
I have to confess to finding the first half of Jonathan Strange… very, very hard going, but adoring the second half and racing through it – so you’re not completely alone 😉
The most epic of my extras would probably be the Tad Williams – he somehow managed to squeeze his usual huge imaginged world into one (admittedly thick) novel.
The others are a bit less epic but if you want well crafted (and haven’t already seen them) check out the Hand, McKinley & Tepper. Deerskin in particualr is a masterpiece in powerful (if harrowing) brief writing.
I am afraid “JS & MN” was your “very, very hard going” all the way through for me, alas. :-\
I am a big fan of Tad Williams and his Memory and Sorrow series “just missed” making it onto my “favourite epic series” post.
Am a big fan of Robin McKinley as well, including Deerskin, but have her tagged for my YA list.:) Will put the others on the TBR list with all the other excellent reccs have received via the comments.
My hands down favourite has to Alan Garner’s ‘The Owl Service.’ I read this again for the ‘I don’t know how many’ time last year and I never read it as a ‘Young Adult’ novel. It’s a very sinister read. If I was going for more adult reads than I am fond of Gaiman’s American Gods, Tolkien’s much under appreciated Silmarillion (not really stand alone) and Robert Sheckley’s ‘Dimension of Miracles’ which I’ve always read as more of fantasy than a SF novel.
An interesting list, Harvey — & I agree with you about The Owl Service being quite powerful and disturbing although I would still ‘probably’ put it in the YA slot. I enjoyed American Gods, but not quite as much as Neverwhere (and haven’t yet got to Anansi Boys, although I likely will.)
Sheckley’s Dimension of Miracles goes on the TBR list. 😉
Love the topic and really appreciate the warm nature of the sharing amongst all the posters. A credit to Helen and all who have contributed. (I have had the misfortune to happen upon much more chippy discussions of similar topics online).
My picks are The Lions of Al Rassan – love all of Kay’s work – which wasn’t love at first read, but has become a go to favourite.
The other doesn’t really conform to your criteria, but I’m gonna mention it even though I can’t really call Matrix either, because I quite like the follow up books. Anyway Wolf in Shadow by David Gemmell is the book, and I just inhale it every time I read it. I feel it can stand alone and be judged thusly despite what came later.
grl
Gregor, I’m glad you enjoyed both the post and the company. I love “Wolf in Shadow” but “didn’t” mention it for the reasons you give–and in the favourite epic series post went with the first Drenai three in the first instance. But the Sipstrassi novels were very original when they first came out.
I wonder if you’d like Rachel Neumeier’s work? Her first was the best McKillip not written by McKillip that I’ve ever read. (CITY IN THE LAKE)
Then she wrote a trilogy featuring griffins which was of equal or better quality and not McKillip like. (Well, maybe the handling of magic was….)Then a couple more standalones with original magic and politics. I like standalones. No major focus on love story threads, either, which is refreshing.
For years my favorite McKillip was FOOL’S RUN, but lately it’s been a toss up between ATRIX WOLFE, BASILISK and OMBRIA. I keep looking for something new by her, but she seems not to have anything coming.
My favorite Kay is LAST LIGHT – I’ve always been grabbed by the Northern tales.
Cherryh’s FORTRESS in the EYE could be read as a standalone and is marvelous, IMO. A wonderful exploration of the shock actual magic suddenly walking in the door has on everything. It didn’t need sequels, although, unlike Hambly’s DRAGONSBANE I enjoy reading most of them (not #5 so much). Like you all, I prefer to pretend the Hambly sequels don’t exist. I also really like CJC’s PALADIN, and GOBLIN MIRROR.
Have you tried Janny Wurts’ solo work? I prefer it to her collaboration with Feist. She has a couple standalones, with TO RIDE HELL’S CHASM getting better comments in general.
I haven’t read Rachel Neumeier yet, but I have heard good things—and like you I am a McKillip fan. I loved Ombria in Shadow — and also Cherryh’s Paladin. I also enjoyed the latter’s Fortress In The Eye Of Time but it’s the only book in the Fortress sequence I’ve read. I ‘think’ I have read one of Janny Wurts solo novels but it was so long ago I’ve forgotten the title! (It wasn’t the one you mention though.) And thank you for commenting.:)
Marion Zimmer Bradley’s The Mists of Avalon is an excellent historical fantasy novel. It’s one of the best and most original retellings of the Arthurian legend (I also enjoyed reading M.K. Hume’s retelling of the Arthurian legend, because it was something a bit different).
It was nice to see C.J. Cherryh’s The Paladin on the list. C.J. Cherryh’s standalone books are interesting. I can recommend The Goblin Mirror and The Dreaming Tree (The Dreaming Tree is an omnibus edition of The Dreamstone and The Tree of Swords and Jewels with revisions).
Have you read Martha Wells? If you haven’t, I can recommend The City of Bones, The Wheel of the Infinite and The Death of the Necromancer (The Death of the Necromancer is part of the Ile-Rien series, but can be read as a standalone book).
Is The Dreaming Tree the one with a fey heroine? In which case, I have read it, but a very long time ago. And I haven’t yet read Martha Wells, but as with Rachel Neumeier I have heard very good things and hope to do so sooner rather than otherwise.
Yes, it’s a book with a fey character (Arafel the Sidhe). It’s beautifully written book.
I hope you have a chance to read Martha Wells soon, because her books are excellent. (I think that everybody who reads The Death of the Necromancer or the Raksura books will be hooked by her writing style.)
Arafel, that’s right–I have read it! I too hope I get the chance to read Martha Wells soon — who knows, after Daughter of Blood is done ‘anything’ could happen. 🙂
I finished reading Paul Kearney’s A Different Kingdom last night and thought that I’d mention it here, because it was an excellent and beautifully written standalone fantasy novel. The author combined several elements in a fluent way. I can highly recommend this novel to everybody who loves good fantasy. (This novel was originally published in 1993 and it was republished in January 2014.)
Thanks for the recommendation.:) I’m glad you mentioned the earlier publication date, because I “thought” I’d heard of it before.